To be funny, satire needs teeth. “Serial Mom” (American; 1994; satirical black comedy/crime/slasher horror; running time 1 hour, 35 minutes; written and directed by John Waters; rated R for violence, gore, language, nudity, sexual situations; in theaters April 13, 1994, available on VOD and streaming services, including Netflix) only nibbles at what it mocks, making for an uneven experience that is only sporadically mildly funny. Kathleen Turner delivers a worthy, campy lead performance even though she is the central figure in what amounts to a one-note joke: What if an ordinary, middle-aged housewife and mother was secretly a serial killer? Though it has moments of clever observational humor, the premise wears thin and gives way to annoyance about the time the film reaches an elongated courtroom scene the outcome of which we can already guess. Waters was mining familiar territory here (familiar to him and other filmmakers), but he wasn’t mining it aggressively enough.
Set (and filmed) in the suburbs of Baltimore (Waters’ hometown), Turner is Beverly Sutphin, a homemaker and mom in an idyllic family that seems straight out of 1957. The décor in Beverly’s home reeks of Good Housekeeping. Beverly’s husband is Eugene (Sam Waterston), a dentist who often is clueless about what is going on around him (and that would help your wife get away with murder). They have two teen (young adult?) children – Misty (Ricki Lake), who is boy crazy; and Chip (Matthew Lillard), a horror movie buff who works at a video rental store. Life seems suburban-y bland for the Sutphins. At least until a couple of people rub Beverly the wrong way, and the next thing you know she is on a killing spree. All it takes is minor annoyance, whether it’s a boy standing up Misty, or a young man who refuses to wear his seatbelt, or the woman who won’t be kind and rewind her returned videotapes. These people deserved to be killed, Beverly reasons, because, well, she’s a psychopath protected by the façade of suburban mom/wife niceness.
Waters, as he so often has, is exploring the absurdity of American life. That includes but is not limited to conformity, conservative values, religion, the public’s cluelessness (or is it denial?), perversion, hypocrisy about perversion and instant celebrity. The latter reaches a zenith when Beverly opts to defend herself from six murder charges, Suzanne Somers (playing herself) shows up at the trial because she wants to play Beverly in the upcoming TV movie, and Beverly wins acquittal (you don’t consider that a spoiler, right?) and becomes a household name and (inexplicably) a feminist icon. And then she murders again. In the courthouse. Because of a fashion faux pax. Turner rolls with the absurdity as she (quickly) morphs into a monster who will smile and offer you strawberries right after a killing. She’s having a blast with the part. But “Serial Mom,” despite moments of sex (played for laughs) and gore (also played for laughs), is too safe and never reaches the level of darkly comedic fun we assume Waters intended. “Serial Mom” had trouble getting into theaters because of a dispute between Waters and studio officials (who didn’t like the movie), and it tanked when it was released, though Waters’ films have never seemed built for mass appeal. Satire can be a tough sell. But if you are trying to sell it, it had better be funny.
My score: 54 out of 100
