“Love, Divided” (in Spanish, “Pared con pared) (Spanish; 2024; rom-com/music; running time 1 hour, 38 minutes; directed by Patricia Font, written by Marta Sánchez; rated TV-14 for language, suggestive dialogue; streaming on Netflix on April 12, 2024) exists. And for fans of the genre, that might be enough. For everyone else, it means there’s not much – beyond its overall implausibility — in this sunny, feel-good love story to hate. But there’s not much reason to watch, either. The concept, that two people on the opposite sides of a wall could fall in love without seeing each other — is a mildly interesting one, even if it was lifted from a 2015 French film called “Blind Date” (this version qualifies as a remake). But everything else here is been there, done that a thousand times over. And perhaps that’s all you ask of your rom-coms.
Valentina (Spanish pop star Aitana) is an aspiring concert pianist whose real dreams center on performing her own pop songs. She moves into a brightly decorated apartment, one provided to her by her discoverer/mentor/manipulator Óscar (Miguel Ángel Munoz), to rehearse for an upcoming audition. Valentina, who is timid and flighty, takes a job that was arranged for her by her cousin (Natalia Rodriguez as Carmen) at a neighborhood juice bar. Living next door to Valentina, separated by a ridiculously thin wall (especially since its made of bricks), is a mad scientist type, albeit a handsome one, David (Fernando Guallar). He is a game designer and, because of one of those plot-device rom-com tragedies, has not left his apartment in three years. David, inexplicably, has built a steampunk-looking contraption that makes ungodly noise designed to drive new tenants out of the apartment next door. Does Spain not have noise laws? Does the building not have an apartment manager? David also is annoyed by Valentina practicing the piano. Valentina is not going to budge, and (through their common, easily heard through wall) they argue, reach a compromise and then, somehow, fall for each other. Will they ever meet face-to-face?
The filmmakers give Aitana, dubbed the “Princess of Spanish Pop,” ample room to do her thing, which is good considering her acting is serviceable at best. Both her and Guallar (and their characters) are bland but likeable. The wall and the romantic leads’ positions on opposite sides of it provide for many ready-made miscommunication/misunderstanding jokes that deliver consistently mild chuckles and little more. If there’s a big problem here is that almost none of this is believable, even by light rom-com standards. And just when “Love, Divided” starts delivering legit emotional moments (thanks largely to that tragedy), it reverts to dumbness. It culminates with Valentina’s audition, one in which she talks to someone backstage while she is playing a Beethoven piece and the judges don’t blink an eye. Ditto the final scene, in which Valentina and David, now in the throes of love, decide to see each other but not use the doors provided with their apartments. Symbolism, anyone? Valentina and David, tear down this wall!
My score: 29 out of 100
